Showing posts with label Phantom Stranger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Phantom Stranger. Show all posts

Saturday, March 14, 2015

Review- TRINITY OF SIN- THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 3: THE CRACK IN CREATION


TRINITY OF SIN- THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 3: THE CRACK IN CREATION (DC, 2015; Softcover)

Collects Trinity Of Sin:The Phantom Stranger #12-22 and Trinity Of Sin:The Phantom Stranger- Future's End #1 (cover dates December, 2013- October, 2014)

Writers: J.M. DeMatteis, Len Wein, and Dan Didio

Artists: Fernando Blanco, Norman Keith Breyfogle, Diego Olmos, Cliff Richards, and Miguel Angel Sepulveda

Colorists: Brad Anderson and Gabriel A. Etlaeb

I have enjoyed this series for the most part...until now. Things seem to slow to a crawl, with the plot becoming an overly wordy holding pattern until it hits the Future's End crossover, which I didn't read. While the following issue after that does a brief dialogue style recap of what happened, a Marvel-style text recap page placed between those issues would have helped smooth things out. As it is I had to go back and double check to make sure that I didn't miss anything the night before. The writing is mostly solid and the artwork is serviceable. 



Once we get past that things get really good. The series cancellation was announced and so DeMatteis sought to wrap things up and go out with a bang. Who else should The Phantom Stranger face but the very “Presence” who has been guiding both he and the New 52 version of The Spectre (featured here as well)? We get as close as a happy ending as Judas Iscariot can get. While I am sad to see this series end I will be happy to save my money, so...thanks, DC?
Junk Food For Thought rating: 3.75 out of 5.

The OCD zone- One can't argue the bang for the buck that you get with this book, 12 issues for $19.99 MSRP. Nice.

Paper stock: Good weight glossy coated stock.

Binding: Perfect bound trade paperback.

Cardstock cover notes: Laminated cardstock cover.

Saturday, May 24, 2014

Review- TRINITY OF SIN- THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 2: BREACH OF FAITH TP


TRINITY OF SIN- THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 2: BREACH OF FAITH (DC, 2014; Softcover)

Collects The Phantom Stranger Nos. 6-8 and Trinity Of Sin: The Phantom Stranger Nos. 9-11 (cover dates May- October, 2013)

Writers: Dan DiDio (plot) and J.M. DeMatteis (script)

Artists: Gene Ha, Fernando Blanco, Philip Tan, Zander Cannon, Dan Davis, Andrew Pepoy, and Jason Paz

Colorists: Art Lyon, Ulises Arreola, and Brad Anderson

News of this series being cancelled hit the airwaves of the Internet as I was finishing this book up. It doesn't surprise me that this series is being cancelled, as The Phantom Stranger has never had much luck in terms of long term popularity. While it doesn't surprise me, the news does disappoint me, because with a little bit of a push, DiDio and DeMatteis could have moved this into some really deep emotional territory.

As finally revealed in Volume 1 of this reboot, The Phantom Stranger is really Judas Iscariot, doomed to wander the Earth trying to right enough wrongs as his penance for betraying Jesus Christ. This really puts an interesting spin on the character. There is a wrinkle in it, though, as while doing his duties he takes over the life of Philip Stark, a serial killer who was planning on killing his family when The Phantom Stranger paid a visit. The Stranger desperately wants to be with his adopted family. This is touched upon but a deeper probe of these scenarios, away from the DC Universe at large, coupled with the macabre could have made this series something very special. Instead it is merely a good read.

Then there is the rest. The God/dog entity who seems to both lead and torment The Phantom Stranger is interesting. I kind of hope that they never reveal if the dog is God or merely a servant or angel. The rebooted Doctor Thirteen is the weak link in this chain. I am not feeling it at all, and he seems to only be here for name recognition and the old timer Easter egg factor. Nightmare Nurse seems to be little more than cosplay fodder, something that DC seems to cater to with all of their female character costumes.

Things go well enough in this book until you hit the speed bump that is issue 11, which is part of the Trinity War crossover (available in the Justice League: Trinity War hardcover). While I am glad that it was included here as well, it would have benefited from one of those Marvel-style text recap pages before the issue to help bring the reader up to speed. All of a sudden Batman, Deadman, and Katana are journeying through a limbo of sorts with The Phantom Stranger and you are left scratching your head. Crossovers suck. Endless line wide crossovers interrupted by intermittent “family”/group titles suck even more. These things suck the life out of titles and fans tend to get tired of them and jump ship. The endless series reboots of the past few years should demonstrate why none of these things are good long term solutions to declining readership. In short, the reason why Image is gobbling up DC's market share at an alarming rate is because they don't demand fans buy eighteen different titles to get a complete story. An average fan could buy only Saga or The Walking Dead and go home happy. There is a lesson to be learned here. A shared universe is great. One that demands that fans spend tons of money on it just to barely keep up is a barrier to entry.

Issue 11 aside, this was a fine read with decent artwork by a slew of different artists. It somehow did not feel disjointed, so kudos to all for that. If you have ever been a fan of The Phantom Stranger then this should be right up your alley. I just wish that DC would do an Archives line of the old series.
Junk Food For Thought rating: 4 out of 5.

The OCD zone- The branding of this title is confusing, even to a hardcore comic fan like myself. No wonder it scared off any potential casual fans and this series was cancelled with issue 22. I wonder if DC will bother collecting the last 11 issues in one chunky book, two separate trades, or not at all.
DVD-style Extras included in this book: Gallery- The Phantom Stranger by Fernando Blanco (2 pages)
Zauriel by Mikel Janin (3 pages)
Paper rating: 4.25 out of 5. Good weight glossy coated stock, perfect for material with modern computer coloring.
Binding rating: 4 out of 5. Perfect bound trade paperback.
Cardstock cover coating rating: 5 out of 5. Nice laminated cardstock which will hold up with repeated handling.


Monday, June 17, 2013

Review- TRINITY OF SIN- THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 1: A STRANGER AMONG US


TRINITY OF SIN- THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 1: A STRANGER AMONG US (DC, 2013; Softcover)

Collects The Phantom Stranger Nos. 0-5 (cover dates November, 2012- April, 2013)

Writer: Dan Didio and J.M.Dematteis (Nos. 4 and 5)

Artists: Brent Anderson (Penciler) and Philip Tan, Rob Hunter, and Scott Hanna (inkers)

Colorists: Ulises Arreola and Jeromy Cox

Like all of these New 52 DC titles, this is equal parts reboot and jumping on point for new and/or lapsed readers. No knowledge of any previous Phantom Stranger stories are necessary for you to understand and enjoy this book. I am not an expert on the character but am very familiar with the Bronze Age stuff. I've read both Showcase Presents phone books and a handful of other appearances, more then enough for me to have a firm grasp on the concept. This reboot almost answers the question of who and what the Phantom Stranger really is. The only thing missing is bold lettering with the name Judas on it. That's right, the Phantom Stranger is basically the same guy who betrayed Jesus Christ and is now trying to atone for his sins, answering to “The Voice”. 


I kind of liked the more ambiguous, strongly hinted at but never really revealed origin that the character had before. This version is spelled out a little too clearly for my tastes. That said, I really enjoyed this book. How could I not? Veteran creators Dan Didio and Brent Anderson heap development on top of development. In the course of this first arc we see the New 52 debut of The Spectre and The Question, as well as Terence Thirteen. In the original series Doctor Thirteen was known as The Ghost Breaker, a skeptic who was always locking horns with The Phantom Stranger, trying to debunk him with science. It was an ongoing thing back then. This version of Terence Thirteen is firmly in The Phantom Stranger's corner, with The Ghost Breaker being an ancestor of his. Again, I prefer the original incarnation. 


In spite of those two major changes, I really enjoyed this. The Phantom Stranger as Judas riff is an interesting one, as he has to continually betray people for the greater good as dictated by The Voice. In this version of the character his necklace is made up of the coins that he got paid for betraying Jesus, and every time he makes amends one of those coins falls off. I'm on board for Volume 2
Junk Food For Thought rating: 5 out of 5.

The OCD zone- The Trinity of Sin branding of this book is a detriment to the series. I believe that it will dissuade, not persuade, a casual buyer into picking up the book. Then again, are there any casual Phantom Stranger fans out there?

Paper rating: 4.5 out of 5. Nice weight glossy coated stock.


Binding rating: 4 out of 5. Glued binding.
Cardstock cover coating rating: 5 out of 5. Excellent quality fully laminated cardstock cover.


Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Review- DEADMAN: BOOK THREE


DEADMAN: BOOK THREE (DC, 2012; Softcover)

Collects World's Finest Comics Nos. 223, 227, The Brave and the Bold No. 133, The Phantom Stranger Nos. 33, 39-41, Superman Family No. 183, and DC Super-Stars No. 18 (cover dates June, 1974- Winter (January-February), 1978)

Writers: Cary Bates, Gerry Conway, Arnold Drake, Bob Haney, Paul Levitz, and Martin Pasko

Artists: Jim Aparo, Tex Blaisdell, Fred Carrillo, Vince Colletta, Dick Dillin, Dick Giordano, Mike Grell, Bob Layton, Kurt Schaffenberger, and Romeo Tanghal

I've read several of the issues collected here before in Showcase Presents The Phantom Stranger Vol. 2, where both Deadman and the Phantom Stranger co-headlined a title. Artist Jim Aparo was a Neal Adams clone in a good way. I love his stuff, and he does the bulk of the artwork in this book. Mike Grell handles the artwork on Phantom Stranger No. 33. Grell is another incredible artist, and his work is woefully uncollected. We need full color Warlord collections, DC! 


The writing in this book is lovably dated Bronze Age goodness. It holds up fairly well here in 2013. It seems to me that if you criticize anything about the writing in modern comics you get labeled a dinosaur. I just feel that while some of these Bronze Age writers may not be technically better writers than modern writers, many of them are better comic book writers. There is something to these third party narratives that add depth to the story. Many modern comics fans hate them; I do not. 


This should be a welcome addition to any self respecting comic fan's bookshelf. I would love to see a Book Four. Does anybody have any idea what would go into it?
Junk Food For Thought rating: 4.75 out of 5.

The OCD zone- Good God, DC! You have neither rhyme nor reason in your collected editions department. Covers are omitted, this volume has no table of contents while Vols. 1 and 2 do...(in a Nancy Kerrigan voice) WHY...WHY???

Linework restoration rating: 4.75 out of 5. Excellent linework restoration with only one or two rough spots.

Color restoration rating: 4 out of 5. My complaint with DC's recoloring is always the same. They go to great lengths to maintain the original color palette, but they choose to use gradient blends which tend to look airbrushed and harsh. They stick out like a sore thumb to my OCD-stricken eyes. If they make the effort to get the colors correct, why not recolor them correctly?

Paper rating: 4 out of 5. This book has a decent weight coated stock which is way too glossy for my taste. It is better than the toilet paper they used to pass off on us in collected editions of vintage material, though.

Binding rating: 4 out of 5. Glued binding. Seems solid enough to hold up with repeated handling.

Cardstock cover coating rating: 5 out of 5. I am thrilled that DC has upped their game and now use the same thick laminated coating on their covers that Marvel does.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Reviews: Showcase Presents The Phantom Stranger Vol. 2; The Complete Dracula; The Astounding Wolf-Man Vol. 4


SHOWCASE PRESENTS THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 2 (DC, 2008; softcover)

Collects The Phantom Stranger Nos.  22-41, The Brave and the Bold Nos. 89, 98, DC Super Stars No. 18, House of Secrets No. 150, and Justice League of America No. 103 (cover dates May, 1970- March, 1978)

After reading over 1,000 pages of Phantom Stranger stories between these two phonebook-sized trade paperbacks and still not knowing the character's origin, I had to head over to Wikipedia (loathe as I am to admit it) for clarification. I like to, you know, read material and interpret and decide for myself what things are. Kind of like how things were in the olden days, before the Internet. The answer is that there is no answer...at least, no definitive answer for his origin. That's cool. I kind of like the mystique and the hints and insinuations, and have my own idea what he truly is. I'm not telling you, though; I'd rather you read it and figure it out for yourself.

The quality of this title nosedives, largely because of "artist" Gerry Talaoc, who is the very definition of a hack. There is nothing about his artwork that I like, and he leaves me cold. The bright spot in the book is when Mike Grell fills-in on Issue 33. I had never seen his artwork but have heard others rave about it. I can see why. He turns in some of the finest comic book artwork that I have ever seen, and I am interested in looking further into his body of work down the road. 

The Phantom Stranger's popularity wanes, and his title turns into first a title with a back-up feature (Frankenstein by Marv Wolfman) and then a co-star on his own title with Deadman. Deadman was also on the outs in terms of popularity, this being after his much celebrated Neal Adams run. The title ends with a whimper, and the Phantom Stranger pops up in a couple more titles before vanishing into the mists of time...at least for a while. There was a mini-series in 1987 and a few odds and ends (thanks, ComicBookDB!) and then only guest appearances. I think that it's high time we got a Phantom Stranger revival.



THE COMPLETE DRACULA (Dynamite, 2010; softcover)

Collects The Complete Dracula Nos. 1-5 (cover dates May- December, 2009)

This is a super dense and text heavy read, but is so darn good. Leah Moore (yes, Alan Moore's daughter) and John Mark Rappion adapt Bram Stoker's original story and add in his 'lost' or 'deleted' segment in the beginning. This is Gothic Horror at its finest, and artist/ colorist Colton Worley really adds a ton to the atmosphere. Every single panel looks like a painting and is gorgeous.  I give this a very high recommendation if you are into this type of stuff.




THE ASTOUNDING WOLF-MAN VOL. 4 (Image, 2010 copyright, actually released in 2011; softcover)

Collects The Astounding Wolf-Man Nos. 19-25 (cover dates October, 2009- November, 2010)

This, the fourth and final trade in the series, leaves many doors open for a hopeful re-visitation down the road. The ending sits well enough with me that I will check out the next Robert Kirkman/ Jason Howard "joint", Super Dinosaur, whenever the trade gets released. Knowing Kirkman,'s timeliness with release dates, that should be sometime in the Fall... of 2012.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

Drowning in my backlog


EX MACHINA VOL. 9: RING OUT THE OLD (Wildstorm/DC, 2010)

Collects Ex Machina Nos. 40-44 and Ex Machina Special No. 4 (cover dates February- October, 2009)

Ex Machina remains one of my favorite titles. Sadly, the series ended with Issue 50, so that gives us only one more trade of Brain K. Vaughn and Tony Harris goodness. This comic is a real page turner, and it will be interesting to see how it all plays out. (Although, given my backlog, I will have to wait for quite some time.) If you want a truly sophisticated "adult" comic that doesn't rely on adolescent pandering to be "mature", then pick this title up.



THE GOLDEN AGE SANDMAN ARCHIVES VOL. 1 (DC, 2004)

Collects material from Adventure Comics Nos. 40-59 and New York World’s Fair Comics 1939 (cover dates July, 1939- February, 1941)

After reading several satisfying volumes of Sandman Mystery Theatre, I decided to dig deeper into the Sandman catalog. For those of you who are not familiar with Sandman Mystery Theatre, it was a title published by Vertigo/DC in the '90s about the Golden Age Sandman. It was set in the '30s and '40s and is a terrific read. I did some digging around online to see if there were any collected editions of said character, and discovered that there was indeed a DC Archive published several years ago.

While not as satisfying a read as Sandman Mystery Theatre, this was still very entertaining and bled charm. Several of the villains from the Vertigo series got their start here. DC's restoration for this volume is mostly excellent, except for the word balloons. I don't know if they worked from scans or photostats when restoring this book, but several word balloons must have been touched up. Sandman is referred to as Bandman several times, B-s are replaced with F-s, and there are a few other minor mistakes. There are less then a dozen throughout the 220-odd pages of the book, but it is more than enough to make my OCD keep me awake at night, tossing and turning over the imperfect restoration of these issues. Oh, and DC only included the covers that had the Sandman on them...I can't stand that!!

So yes, before the relaunched Sandman by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, before the guy actually made of sand created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko appeared in Amazing Spider-Man, and before Neil Gaiman made waves with his incarnation of the Sandman, there was THIS Sandman. I guess that we could call him OG Sandman...or not.



TOMB OF DRACULA OMNIBUS VOL. 2 (Marvel, 2009)

Collects Dr. Strange No. 14, Giant-Size Dracula Nos. 5 and Tomb of Dracula Nos. 32-70 (cover dates May, 1975- August, 1979)

After many months in the backlog and a couple of months of intermittent reading, I finished this nearly 800 page monster tome (pun intended). This is dense, text-heavy Bronze Age goodness. Tomb of Dracula was writer Marv Wolfman and artists Gene Colan and Tom Palmer's tour De force. The series was to be cancelled with issue 70, but work on issues 71 and 72 was already well underway. They delayed issue 70 by several months, made it double-sized, and it was re-tooled to be the series finale. Had Marvel not included the extra, unfinished, unused pages, I would have never known that the published ending was not the creators' original intention. The ending was executed flawlessly and was a satisfying end to this epic.

This series is being reissued again as a series of affordable trade paperbacks for the masses. I think that are one or two of them out already, and they clock in around 200 pages each. I'd recommend this to any fans of the Horror or vampire genres that haven't already checked them out.



POWER PACK CLASSIC VOL. 2 (Marvel, 2010)

Collects Power Pack Nos. 11-17, Marvel Graphic Novel- Power Pack & Cloak and Dagger: Shelter From The Storm and Uncanny X-Men No. 195 (cover dates June- December, 1985; MGN, 1989)

The first thing that I thought of when I heard that Disney bought Marvel is 'finally, we will get a Power Pack movie'. No, really. It makes perfect sense for this to be a Pixar CGI flick. While I would love to see them modeled after June Brigman's artwork, they would likely be modeled after the more recent, cartoon-y, cutesy, mang-ish GuriHiru artwork.Whatever it takes, I think that these characters would be excellent in a cartoon flick.

I bought all of these issues off of the stands, with the exception of the Marvel Graphic Novel with Cloak and Dagger. That was the weak link in the book. Everything else is wonderful. The writing and artwork all hold up very well a quarter century later.



MARVEL MASTERWORKS: GOLDEN AGE SUB-MARINER VOL. 3 (Marvel, 2009)

Collects Sub-Mariner Comics Nos. 9-12 (cover dates Spring, 1943- Winter, 1943-44)

Wow, this has a steep decline in quality from the earlier Bill Everett written and drawn issues. Everett was away serving Uncle Sam during the time that these issues were made. The stories starring the series back-up feature, The Angel (by Gustav Schrotter) are a better read than the Sub-Mariner during this era. In "The Battle of Kwangto" (Sub-Mariner #12), Namor deals with a Captain Stark at Naval Headquarters. Now, I'm going to go all Roy Thomas and retroactively insert him into continuity as a relative of Tony Stark (Iron Man). It doesn't fly in the face of Marvel continuity (1961-on) and therefore, by his definition, BECOMES a part of the continuity. Retroactively, of course.

Sub-Mariner's primary enemy during this time are the Japanese, and he refers to them in any number of unfavorable ways. This WAS wartime, and they WERE the enemy. I look forward to future volumes, as I know that Everett returns down the road. His '50s Sub-Mariner ranks among some of the finest comic books of that decade; go check out the Marvel Masterworks: Atlas Era Heroes volumes and see for yourself.



AGE OF BRONZE VOL. 1: A THOUSAND SHIPS (Image, Fourth Printing, 2008)

Collects Age of Bronze Nos. 1-9 (cover dates November, 1998- November, 2000)

Eric Shanower has crafted a compelling and engaging account of the Trojan War. His artwork is very detail-oriented, with each panel having nuances that require you to stop and look in order to fully appreciate it all. The story flows nicely, being as dense or as decompressed as the scene dictates. There are segments that you fly though, and others that make Chris Claremont look like Brian Michael Bendis. This comic book is both entertaining and educating, and I would recommend it to open-minded readers.  

My only complaint is that the original issue covers are not included. They would have made for nice chapter markers, as there are none in the entire book. It is impossible to tell where one issue ended and the other began, as it read like one seamless story. 



AGE OF BRONZE VOL. 2: SACRIFICE (Image, Second Printing, 2005)

Collects Age of Bronze Nos. 10-19 (cover dates February, 2001- March, 2004)

The artwork and story remain exquisitely well done, crammed with details. I find this sort of 'historical fiction', or infotainment, to be lots of fun. I enjoy this series because it shows what comic books can be capable of being with enough thought and effort. I am primarily a Marvel guy can appreciate a well done title like this.



SHOWCASE PRESENTS THE PHANTOM STRANGER VOL. 1 (DC, 2006)

Collects Showcase No. 80 and The Phantom Stranger Nos. 1-21 (cover dates February, 1969- October, 1972)

OK, who do I petition to get this series done in color and in hardcover? I bought this on a whim because I have been intrigued by the character's appearance in the other DC titles that I have read (like the Superman- Man of Steel trades), so I skimmed my toe in the waters of this phone book and...wow! These are superb comic books, written largely by Len Wein (some guy who created a little known character called Wolverine a few years later) with artwork by Jim Aparo, a Neal Adams clone of the highest order, and Neal Adams himself. Adams in an absolute master of the art form, often imitated but seldom duplicated...although Aparo is pretty darn close. Adams mostly sticks to cover art, but what covers they are!

The Phantom Stranger's 'adversary', or counterpoint, is a skeptic named Dr. Thirteen, the Ghost Breaker, whose primary goal is to prove that the Stranger is a fraud. Mystery heaped upon mystery, they still don't really tell you the character's true origin or nature of his powers some 540 pages later. I have Volume 2 in my queue, and can't wait to tear into it.



THE FLASH CHRONICLES VOL. 1 (DC, 2009)

Collects Showcase Nos. 4, 8, 13, 14 and The Flash Nos. 105, 106 (cover dates October, 1956- May, 1959)

Like most little boys who grew up in the late '70s, I loved the SuperFriends cartoon on Saturday morning. The Flash was one of the characters on that show, but for whatever reason I decided that DC sucked when I was around 8 or 9 and never read a Flash comic book until now. This trade paperback was in the 1/2 off section at the Motor City Comic Con last May, and since I've enjoyed the other Chronicles trades so much I figured that I'd give this a try. Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman all rocked in the Golden Age of Comics. The Green Lantern Chronicles trades skipped the Golden Age version of the character and skipped right ahead to the Silver Age version. The Flash Chronicles did the same thing. Whereas Green Lantern has a zany, fun vibe going on, Flash kinda sucks.

One of the first things that you have to adopt as a comic book fan is a healthy suspension of disbelief. Many fans erroneously state that they like Marvel because their comics are more realistic. I prefer to say that they are more believable, in that the pseudo-science used to define a character's powers has a set of parameters, and the character and their power operate within them. DC seems to have a whatever suits the story type vibe to their powers. I have an extremely hard time swallowing the concept of Flash. Barry Allen is a scientist who is struck by lightning, and that along with some chemicals gives him the power to run fast. So fast that he can break the time barrier or move at 1/1,000,000th of a second. For one thing, I doubt that his lungs could enable him to breathe running at those speeds, so he'd essentially 'drown'. For another, his costume doesn't seem to be made of some fricition resistant "unstable molecules" (as Marvel calls them), so it would be scorched right off of him. His skin would likely also be peeled off him and he'd die. So yeah, while I can buy an alien crashing on Earth and giving Hal Jordan a power ring to become Green Lantern, or a baby crash-landing on an alien planet and raised by farmers, or a boy witnessing his parents murdered in front of him and vowing to rid the world of evil...heck, I can even buy Paradise Island and the whole Greek God Wonder Woman crap, but I can't swallow this. Gorilla Grodd completely rocks, though, so not all is lost. Also, the Flash's costume is among the more dynamic ones in all of comic books. So yeah, The Flash sucks...sort of.



HERCULES: FULL CIRCLE (Marvel, 2009)

Collects Marvel Graphic Novel No. 37 and material from Marvel Age Nos. 4, 65, Marvel Comics Presents Nos. 39-41 and Marvel Tales No. 197 (cover dates July, 1983- January, 1990)

Top notch stuff by Bob Layton. I read the old Hercules- Prince of Power trade years ago and loved it, and this hardcover picks up where that left off. This has a light-hearted tone to it, and even though Hercules is an arrogant buffoon, you can't help but root for him.