SUPERGOD (Avatar, 2011; Softcover)
Collects Supergod Nos. 1-5 (cover dates October, 2009- October, 2010)
Writer: Warren Ellis
Artist: Garrie M. Gastonny
More of a terrifying look at our manmade need for salvation by the hands of something greater than us than a regular superhero book, Supergod is a mental exercise in fathoming the unfathomable. What happens when the deity doesn't need the disciples? Ellis writes some heady stuff here, and I enjoyed this immensely. I am enjoying everything that I read from Avatar Press.
The OCD zone- Wax coated cardstock cover, nice paper grade, this is par for the course quality product from Avatar Press.
THE RED WING (Image, 2011; Softcover)
Collects The Red Wing Nos. 1-4 (cover dates July- October, 2011)
Writer: Jonathan Hickman
Artist: Nick Pitarra
Time travel is always an intriguing concept to explore, and Jonathan Hickman has a fresh spin on it. The problem with this series is that Nick Pitarra's artwork employs a 'cinematic scope' which basically means that they rely heavily on pictures and less on words. Cinematic styling does not work in comic books for a number of reasons. First, comic books have no sound. You, the reader, supply the sound of voices and objects in your mind. A movies does that for you, and it is part of the sensory experience. There is no musical score or soundtrack in a comic book to heighten suspenseful parts of the story. Using comic books as a storyboard flipbook is not only lazy, it is lame.
See that image up above? Looks like crap, right? Some stupid dot on a two page, all black spread. That's supposed to be a shuttle launching from a crashing ship. They show this same scene four times, with each double page spread showing the shuttle moving a few inches with no words on any of the pages. What a waste of time, and what padding! Eight pages of a comic book were dedicated to this. Horrible, horrible, lazy decompressed writing. That might have been effective for a half page layout, showing the shuttle touching down across 4 or 5 narrow panels, but eight pages? This outcraps the worse Bendis writing. Congratulations, Hickman! You've raised the bar on the suck-scale.
All in all, this is a mediocre read, and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone. The characters are flat and lifeless, and the time shifts feel vanilla. I honestly didn't care if any of these characters lived or died. I am sure that this will sell boatloads because Jonathan Hickman's name is on the cover. I sure hope so, as I will be dumping this piece of crap on eBay during my next purging and would like to recoup as much of my money as possible.
The OCD zone- The production values on this trade paperback are top notch. High quality paper with a wax coated cardstock cover, this has a pleasing feel and heft to it. It's a shame that it sucked so much.
Follow my blog on Facebook.
Did you forget about the Powers comic from Bendis that featured cave men talking to each other in cave speak through the whole comic? That was a complete waste of time and money. It didn't add anything to the story that he couldn't have put in a couple of pages.
ReplyDelete